to be fair, ICLR is a far cry from what Yann is suggesting in that piece. I'm not questioning the need for reform. My question is why didn't the push for reform succeed back then, and what can we learn from that? (in the spirit of "Everyone will not just")
Comments
Do _not_ check arxiv regularly, it’s bad for you.
https://www.stat.cmu.edu/~brian/rm/764-2016/week05/refereeing/Larry-Abolish-the-Peer-Review.pdf