decided to make a new tierlist after playing shadow generations, and sleeping on superstars a bit
only includes games that play SOMEWHAT similarly, so no racing games or anything like that, except r and rivals games
now fight me
only includes games that play SOMEWHAT similarly, so no racing games or anything like that, except r and rivals games
now fight me
Comments
- each tier is ordered
- this is based equally on personal enjoyment and the impression the game has left on me. if i was going with "which game i think is the best" mania would be at the top, and games like cd, advance 2, heroes, and r would be a tier lower
- superstars could easily be at the top of B if the bosses weren't so dogshit. it's a shame
- rivals 1 ranks better because i dont think any of the changes or additions in rivals 2 address the flaws of the first game, and the new rival battles are pretty shit lol
- sonic 06 isn't F tier only because it has Really Good level design sometimes
everything that's above sonic generations 3ds are worth giving a shot regardless tho imo
really, the beauty of the franchise is that while there are some fantastic games, even the ones that are not so great have some cool stuff worth experiencing going on with them... most of the time
Also :)
advance 2 is definitely a game that becomes more fun once you learn the levels though, i hold my stance that it's not a very good experience on your first playthrough
Hit me up and we can get this problem fixed within a day.