[guesswork alert] I have the impression some people get favorable reviewers' evaluation based on their reputational prestige. I really really hope my impression is wrong! Is it?
Comments
Log in with your Bluesky account to leave a comment
Also, a lot of these authors aren't actually famous in the usual sense. You can find people with absurdly high h-indexes in a domain you're familiar with yet have never even seen their names, because they publish in... less reputable venues, to put it politely.
It's not impossible to guess who the author is from an anonymous manuscript. You might not be 100% sure but you can have a relatively small set of "suspects"...
Comments