She does make it clear she wants her life to matter, the sacrifices to get her there to have meaning (not long before she is knocked out I think). He ignored that wish.
The doctors were wrong to disregard her wishes too, but they didn't massacre an entire building to do it.
An entire building of people who wanted to murder an innocent girl to (probably not actually) save humanity regardless of what her personal wishes were. Not sure why their number matters here, they got what they deserved. Fuck around and find out.
I don't think the grunts possibly not having full context on why he was trying to get to the operating room really matters here- they chose to shoot at him, he wasn't any more wrong to shoot back than he was to save Ellie in the first place.
Past that Joel even says that any Firefly who knew enough would just come after Ellie if he let them live, which is why he kills Marlene. While Abby's after Joel rather than Ellie she basically proves him right in the sequel!
I'd agree.. Except they are defending a base, it's their job to attack him.
The 2nd game doesn't prove anyone right. They all did the wrong thing. They all made others suffer for their own mistakes.
Comments
Not a child. He can't makelife altering decisions for her because he knew her for a few months
But for her
We let 14 yrs work. Work is dangerous (no matter how safe we try to make it).
Honestly the issue is he took her choice.
And he gave her no chance to have a say then, or went she got older because everyone dead.
The doctors were wrong to disregard her wishes too, but they didn't massacre an entire building to do it.
The military grunts all knew?
The 2nd game doesn't prove anyone right. They all did the wrong thing. They all made others suffer for their own mistakes.