What 2 time Superbowl QB is not in the HoF, name 1 other then Eli! Only 1 ever and that is: Jim Plunkett is the only eligible quarterback who has won multiple Super Bowls and is not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame! Eli will be voted in, be real here!
It's exactly what you said about the defense bro. They were average at best in those seasons, except the super bowl. Just like eli. He was never a top 5 qb in any season. Getting hot twice doesn't change that
And he ended with a 0.500 record. This guy was never elite. Hall of Fame should be reserved for elite players. But because his last name is Manning, he'll make it
He is elite and he, along with a great defense, led the Giants to 2 SB wins, including beating the undefeated Patriots and winning every playoff game ON THE ROAD. Then there’s his consecutive starts stat (no thanks to McAdoo). The man deserves to be in the HOF.
Comments
vs:
1/
He belongs.
His defense didn't carry both super bowls. Strahan was irrelevant to the first one.