The findings were somewhat surprising and puzzling, though in hindsight ours make more sense, see discussion.
We asked red team assessors to reanalyze our data and they came up with the same findings.
We reached out to the original authors and had a positive discussion.
We asked red team assessors to reanalyze our data and they came up with the same findings.
We reached out to the original authors and had a positive discussion.
Comments
Grateful for the original authors for sharing their materials, and engaging in a constructive debate, also in peer review.
Grateful for our red-team assessors for their help.
Depending on what you consider the core hypotheses, it's tricky what to conclude. I would say mixed results, at best.
Poll:
https://x.com/giladfeldman/status/1639889109236826112
https://osf.io/bwmtr/
Hopefully things are slowly changing, atleast in PSPB.