Not actually true
Recent studies reveal that about 44.9% of Israeli Jews have Mizrahi (Middle Eastern/North African) origins, 44.2% are Ashkenazi (European descent), 7.9% claim mixed heritage, and 3% are Ethiopian Jews.
All people ultimately have 100% human heritage from Africa. Claiming descent from somewhere a couple of millennia ago gives no group the right to displace, oppress and genocide another group that has also lived there for many centuries
For sure it doesn't justify oppression but claiming Jews are aliens to Israel is a blatant lie. Many Palestinians are also descended from Muslim settlers from other areas of the Ottoman Empire, and there have always been Jews in Israel.
I didn't say Jews are alien to Israel I disagreed with someone saying all Palestinians are Jordanian by making the equally ridiculous statement that if that's true then all Israelis are European
That's like saying there are no Jews, they're just white East Europeans. People can identify as they choose and Palestinians have lived in Palestine longer than most European nations or even the US have existed. So shut up with this shit
Not sure where this is getting us though. Other than that, as with South Africa, an apartheid state like Israel is unsustainable in its present form and that equal rights to statehood, citizenship and free enjoyment of their homeland must be accorded to all indigenous Palestinians
Whatever anyone's origins I think most reasonable people now accept that an apartheid Israeli state, where only people considered Jews have full rights but indigenous Palestinians (who continue to be expropriated and genocided) have none, is utterly untenable
My point is that Israel needs Rhodesia's treatment. Completely dissolve this colony, make the colonists return to Europe, and give their colony's land back to its natives.
I don't think that's a realistic aim. What you may find though is that in a state where all are treated equally and fairly, those committed to it will stay and build a better future together, while those unhappy with loss of supremacy will leave of their own accord
I don't think you understand my point. It's not realistic to imagine Israel will be able to coexist with Palestine because Israel is a state built entirely on the idea that the holocaust was entirely the Palestinians' fault for "kicking their ancestors" out.
Palestinians won't be able to survive as long as Israel lives. Israel is a white ethno state that blames the holocaust entirely on palestians and not the nazis because they believe palestians forced their ancestors to move to Europe(which again, is utter bullshit cause they're white poles).
I'm not competent to comment on how Jews see their history, but I agree there's no room for an apartheid Israel any more than previously an apartheid South Africa. Not without challenges, which continue, at least South Africa moved relatively peacefully to "rainbow nation" for all
Israelis are actively anti-Semitic because they believe you have to be semitic to be a " real jew". Hence why they treat ethiopian jews and arab jews as second-class citizens. The irony is, they themselves aren't semitic, DNA tests have proved it. But they refuse to acknowledge it.
No they are not. Know your history before posting. Palestine existed before Jordan. The British colonized the Middle East along with France. Jordan was given "statehood" in 1946. They along with other Arab countries condemned the creation of Israel at the expense of Palestinians in Palestine.
No, they're Palestinians. But the OG Jews were jordanian since ancient Israel wasn't even in Palestine, it was in Jordan. You're so keen to protect the reconstrucation of the state of Israel when you idiots couldn't even figure out what country ancient Israel was even located in!
Comments
Recent studies reveal that about 44.9% of Israeli Jews have Mizrahi (Middle Eastern/North African) origins, 44.2% are Ashkenazi (European descent), 7.9% claim mixed heritage, and 3% are Ethiopian Jews.
https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2016/03/08/identity/#:~:text=Israeli%20Jews%20are%20nearly%20evenly,associated%20with%20their%20ancestral%20roots.
40- 45% are middle Eastern according to this piece.