Yes I did not see any dataset, did you? to me it does not seem unreasonable to try to reproduce such an important work. at least i think to check the database of errors found, but i could not find it on the paper either. - ThreadSky

brettbuttliere.bsky.social • 49 days ago

Yes I did not see any dataset, did you?

to me it does not seem unreasonable to try to reproduce such an important work. at least i think to check the database of errors found, but i could not find it on the paper either.

Comments

meredithmicrobial.bsky.social•49 days ago

I saw a really curt response to you that to me was bordering on disrespectful and certainly stank of intellectual snobbery. I couldn’t imagine talking to someone just so in person, but we all know the internet remains quite a wild place of vitriol and misunderstanding.

brettbuttliere.bsky.social•49 days ago

I think it is what she is known for

ocasapiens.bsky.social•49 days ago

Fortunately, for years she's been known for being courteous, patient when training hundreds of science sleuths, and helping perplexed reporters to understand how small "mistakes" can be hugely misleading.

meredithmicrobial.bsky.social•49 days ago

I’m sorry to hear that. May your journey in knowledge continue and bear fruit, friend I’ve not met yet.

brainchip.bsky.social•49 days ago

She told you how she got the data. You can do the analysis yourself now right? It's all from OA so the raw data is at your disposal.

brettbuttliere.bsky.social•49 days ago

https://bsky.app/profile/brettbuttliere.bsky.social/post/3lfihhvszjc2d

brainchip.bsky.social•49 days ago

Can't imagine she sends tens of social media replies shifting the goal post every time Brett.

brettbuttliere.bsky.social•48 days ago

who is shifting the goals? I asked some simple questions, she could not answer, I asked her for her data so i could do it myself, she has not and cannot apparently provide them.

brettbuttliere.bsky.social•48 days ago

the first question i asked was why she summarized to papers she said she had no good reason i asked how many images were in there she said they didnt count.

lots of people coming with bad arguments but its ok for me

brainchip.bsky.social•48 days ago

You literally admitted to not reading the paper properly to begin with. You did get answers to your questions. You were given the source of all the data and how it was processed. You are just too lazy to do it yourself and seek excuses.

Comments

Posting Rules

Reply