There's hidden deaths from coal power, even with nuclear accidents, you kill 3,000X more people for the same power. Chernobyl was the Soviet Union, Windscale was a weapons ( not power ) reactor, Three Mile Island had in fact a minimal release, and Fukushima resulted from inept regulation. 3/13 - ThreadSky

johnasydney.bsky.social • 73 days ago

There's hidden deaths from coal power, even with nuclear accidents, you kill 3,000X more people for the same power. Chernobyl was the Soviet Union, Windscale was a weapons ( not power ) reactor, Three Mile Island had in fact a minimal release, and Fukushima resulted from inept regulation. 3/13

Comments

johnasydney.bsky.social•73 days ago

Fukushima, well I there I worry about our human frailties, and our ability to properly regulate things, because the fault really rests with our human "original sin" rather than nuclear technology in itself. Still, you kill fewer people overall with nuclear. 4/13

tasmaniacturtle.bsky.social•73 days ago

But human frailties are fixed now?

johnasydney.bsky.social•73 days ago

At the other end of the scale, I recall an administrator of a nuclear power station, that he signed 500 bits of paper a day. Yes, nuclear obliges a regulatory framework with good scrutiny, but driven by unrealistic fears, that's not necessarily what we'll get. 5/13

tasmaniacturtle.bsky.social•73 days ago

Non sequitur

johnasydney.bsky.social•73 days ago

OK, coal fired power stations, what about renewables? I'm happy for household solar cells, but it is a private initiative. While you can pull less power from the grid, it harder to feed more of that power back. And houses take up 30% of our energy consumption, you can only do so much. 6/13

tasmaniacturtle.bsky.social•73 days ago

Four million households have solar panels. That's quite a private initiative.
It's also more electricity generation than the entire coalition "plan"

johnasydney.bsky.social•73 days ago

Yes, let's try to make power users more flexible - aluminium extraction electrolytic cells with better "idle" states - but limiting the power use in hospitals and other places is a bit silly - you can only go so far. 7/13

tasmaniacturtle.bsky.social•73 days ago

Nobody has proposed that

johnasydney.bsky.social•73 days ago

Cranking out distributed solar & wind with a matching 24 hour grid is a gargantuan task, like a space or atomic bomb program. Mines soak up all the tradies in local towns - think about this on a capital city wide scale. Ramping up will be challenging, in terms of the diversions in the economy. 8/13

johnasydney.bsky.social•73 days ago

Nuclear compares well, in terms what you need to put in for the result. We could try to import foreign workers - really we should subtract the cost of training from our foreign aid budget, but in any case, rather than exporting carbon, we'd then be exporting economic chaos. 9/13

Comments

Posting Rules

Reply