We used to do this, and then we decided to no longer do it anymore and make it a crime against humanity. Ethnic cleansing.
We also used to do slavery, but we don't do that anymore despite the historical use of it. Fucks sake.
Stunning. You would think that in a moment in time when we have Holocaust deniers on the rise, that Jewish people would steer clear of genocide. And quick reminder, Jews were “relocated” out of their homes and cities with millions never heard from again….😞😞
I feel like it's important to note Tablet is a hard-right conservative rag and has been for years. Genuinely some of the worst pro-z propaganda being put out.
This glittering vision of ‘redevelopment’ would be presented as progress—a shining example of prosperity rising from destruction. But beneath the surface lies a darker truth: the systematic genocide of a people and their culture.
We all need to make sure the Americans around us don’t get confused. Forced relocation is genocide. When white Euro settlers forced 1st Nation Peoples onto reservations, that was genocide. Please make sure the Americans around you are not confused. The Palestinians aren’t going anywhere, but home.🌳
By doing what? Following laws? Getting old? Letting a younger candidate run? No matter what he did, half were going to blame him for everything. Also, while I'm a huge pessimist, even I didn't think these idiots would do what they're doing so quickly. Look around. The American people DID "THIS".
22 USC 2378-1: No assistance shall be furnished under this chapter or the Arms Export Control Act to any country when it is made known to the President that the such country prohibits or otherwise restricts, directly or indirectly, the transport or delivery of US humanitarian assistance.
No, the Israelis did this. The Israelis took Palestinian home and lands in 1947 and have continued to do so. Biden was wrong to totally commit to the Israelis. But Netanyahu is responsible. Israel's responsible.
They couldn't actually have done any of that without US money. Therefore US is complicit and to blame. We knew they were committing war crimes and continued to fund them.
Yes, the US is complicit. But Israel, Giron Ben David, the founder of Zionism, paved the way. We must continue to push for a more Pro-Palestinian policy. At least when we get a government that's more responsive to us. Trump sure as he'll ain't going to help the Palestinians.
It is interesting to me that Trump has no fear about putting a hotel there? Could this mean that Hamas isn’t really as big a threat as Israel is trying to say it is? Could they be lying?
Perhaps the Palestinians should be relocated to, oh, I don't know, let's call them "camps" that would be built with their own rail lines, and to save money build large communal "showers."
If an “Islamic American” publication had an article supporting the mass deportation of Jews from the occupied state, it would be covered as radicalised batsh1t crazy fundamentalism.
We humans are always seeking resolution. Victims become perpetrators when our wounds are not treated. We humans invariably perpetrate the transgressions we received. Such suffering here.
@mehdirhasan.bsky.social I recommend checking the likely connection to Jared Kushner and his big money friends and the crown prince in SA as Gaza might become now a part of the NEOM project. 🤔
Mass relocation. Yeah. That’s what the Sultan and his Turks called the death marches of my Armenian ancestors from their homeland, where they had lived for thousands of years. Then they renamed all the cities. Harput is now Elazig. Wiped off the map, like its people. Barbaric.
I highly doubt a substantive number of people voted for Trump over Biden/Harris’ support for Israel, of all issues. More likely, they either voted Green or not at all.
This is Biden/Harris’ fault for enabling genocide in the first place.
Yes it is. It's well known that the label "Ethnic cleansing", was made up to make up a fake differentiator between "real genocides", and the genocides that the west had undertaken.
To do an ethnic cleansing, is to do a genocide, obviously.
The Jewish folks have no mercy for the Palestinian people who basically live in an open air prison. War criminal Netanyahu was RESPONSIBLE for the October 7 massacre. He FUNDED HAMAS to mollify them and they took the opportunity to attack while Netanyahu was busy trying rig the Courts.
Well! It was God’s promise to Abraham & Moses (Gen 15:18) & in Numbers too
They often cite Hamas’s mantra as evil, but their own Torah says that they would drive out the inhabitants & the land would be their’s, from the river to the sea
Essentially their claim is a 4,000 year old fantasy
You would think, given 20th C history, that they really would want to avoid encouraging this sort of thing. Do they not realise these people will eventually turn on them? Seeing much the same thing in the Jewish Chronicle too.
It’s called a pogrom and ethnic cleansing, but they wouldn’t have any history with that would they? If they did they would never make this argument, right?
Netanyahu has accomplished a public relations coup by convincing many outside Israel that any opposition to his particular policies is the same as anti-Semitism. So right-wingers who hate brown people and Muslims can scream that it's anti-Semitic not to promote the elimination of Palestinians.
I mean, the Abrahamic religions as a whole seem to be ok with genocide when they are in power. It’s not exclusive to Jewish people. The ideology of “we have the right religion and everyone else deserves death and/or hell” is a useful tool for bad actors to exploit
Speaking from a woman’s point of view all religions are bad. They’re all formed to oppress you by someone who wants absolute power over you.They make up a bunch of lies and stories, convince you with magic tricks that it’s truth. Next thing you know you’re washing some asshole’s feet with fancy oils
It is completely unacceptable that a U.S. President so wantonly disregards the legitimacy and needs of the Palestinian peoples. This “relocation” would represent a gross violation of Geneva Convention IV, Article 49—full stop!
Their claim to the land is no less important than the Israelis. If they leave there is every indication they will never be allowed back….certainly not to their own property, or whatever is left. Scattering these people to the winds is genocide.
Sick… and all in the name of what? GREED, THAT’S WHAT!
Netanyahu and Hamas are war criminals! Trump is complicit in the ethnic cleaning of the Palestinian people! 🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼
I’m praying for all that were harmed in this horrific conflict!🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
1) There is no moral case for relocation.
2) There is no genocide taking place in Gaza, despite the efforts of people like you to twist the meaning of the word to fit your twisted narrative.
3) You are a Jewhating hack.
4) There is no moral case for relocation.
1) We agree!
2) As soon as you step outside the Israeli propaganda bubble, it is pretty obvious there is.
3) You're conflating anti-zionism/critique of Israel with antisemitism, but these are obviously different things.
4) We still agree.
Hi Tim.
Glad we agree on 1 & 4.
Re 2) There is only 1 group with genocidal intent and that is #Hamas. If we were committing genocide, we would have made Gaza one big parking lot on 10/8.
Re 3) Zionism is the modern term for Shivat Zion, returning to Zion, which we prayed for 3x/day for 2k yrs.
The obvious response is that the Palestinian people have been "relocated" before, which had disastrous results and brought us here.
Not to mention the disingenuous use of the word relocation to describe a forcible eviction under penalty of death. I think the correct term is "Final Solution".
Well, history tells us that if Palestinians are expelled from their country, they aren't allowed back.
And Israel have no qualms about massacring them even when they are in refugee camps in neighbouring countries.
After WWII Jews said, "Never again." I realize what a leader of a country does doesn't reflect all of those people's agreement, as a magazine, it's a bit late for apologies.
While heading to prison, the man says to his children, .."sorry for murdering your mom."
The Christian MAGA nazi’s are about to eat Zionist faces, while zionists still think Palestine is the threat.
It’s OK to say you feel conflicted opposing genocide when it is linked to yr family/legacy/identity. It’s OK to say you feel conflicted. But you still have to oppose genocide. Stand w 🇵🇸
Comments
We also used to do slavery, but we don't do that anymore despite the historical use of it. Fucks sake.
Gonna need a bit more specificity.
There. Fixed his shitty headline
But even for them this is low
Please read & share
https://www.plagueisland.com/p/monuments-to-genocide-the-redevelopment
https://hrgshr.state.gov/en/info
Just, "wow."
Why do we live in the stupidest timeline?
And that includes a week with Trump and the sycophants blaming Ukraine for being attacked every hour on the hour.
How is it possible for people- who've been running from this exact thing for 100s of years - to do this to others
I’m wondering if they are pleased with their decision?
This is Biden/Harris’ fault for enabling genocide in the first place.
A liberal's favourite past time.
A maga's favorite past time.
You are just as brainwashed as republicans are!
To do an ethnic cleansing, is to do a genocide, obviously.
They often cite Hamas’s mantra as evil, but their own Torah says that they would drive out the inhabitants & the land would be their’s, from the river to the sea
Essentially their claim is a 4,000 year old fantasy
You are really good at playing into the stereotypes about Argentina having absorbed the majority of the world's Hitler-particles post-war.
Israel is the great evil here, you Nazi-spawn moron.
Or, in Trump's America, even the Jewish people are becoming Holocaust deniers?
(Standard disclaimer about not supporting the survival of Hamas or any other asshole terrorist organization.)
Religion is about controlling people.
They're simply doing what the controllers have programmed them to do.
Zionist propaganda has for many decades held a death grip on Israelis and Americans, that grip is slipping in America and they are scared.
https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/moral-case-mass-relocation-joseph-schechtman
"We will use mass relocation to assist Palestinians in evacuating the area, and for those who will not leave, enhanced interrogation will be employed"
Read it and weep.
Netanyahu and Hamas are war criminals! Trump is complicit in the ethnic cleaning of the Palestinian people! 🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼
I’m praying for all that were harmed in this horrific conflict!🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
2) There is no genocide taking place in Gaza, despite the efforts of people like you to twist the meaning of the word to fit your twisted narrative.
3) You are a Jewhating hack.
4) There is no moral case for relocation.
Hope that helped clarify, Mehdi.
2) As soon as you step outside the Israeli propaganda bubble, it is pretty obvious there is.
3) You're conflating anti-zionism/critique of Israel with antisemitism, but these are obviously different things.
4) We still agree.
Glad we agree on 1 & 4.
Re 2) There is only 1 group with genocidal intent and that is #Hamas. If we were committing genocide, we would have made Gaza one big parking lot on 10/8.
Re 3) Zionism is the modern term for Shivat Zion, returning to Zion, which we prayed for 3x/day for 2k yrs.
That the cult members here are 'innocents' in the
horror that Israel is perpetrating.
Not to mention the disingenuous use of the word relocation to describe a forcible eviction under penalty of death. I think the correct term is "Final Solution".
#FuckIsrael
#FuckTrump
What part of the US is Israel?
And Israel have no qualms about massacring them even when they are in refugee camps in neighbouring countries.
While heading to prison, the man says to his children, .."sorry for murdering your mom."
Yeah... um, NO
🤦🏼♀️
It’s OK to say you feel conflicted opposing genocide when it is linked to yr family/legacy/identity. It’s OK to say you feel conflicted. But you still have to oppose genocide. Stand w 🇵🇸