2/n
For:
- encourages more comprehensive work
- aligns with community preprint trends
- eliminates need for supplemental materials which are often confusing
- does not create artificial incentive to write confusing terse narratives
For:
- encourages more comprehensive work
- aligns with community preprint trends
- eliminates need for supplemental materials which are often confusing
- does not create artificial incentive to write confusing terse narratives
Comments
Against:
- Will increase the reviewer burden (but market effects will likely balance that)
- Page limits encourages good writing discipline
- May create burdens for low-resourced authors