I think it will be awful. Junior people won't dare posting honest-but-negative reviews, some will avoid reviewing entirely for this reason, others will write excessively praiseful reviews. Aren't blind reviews in place for the same reason as secret ballots in democracies?
I just don't agree with this, I think plenty of junior people will be happy to put out precise, careful negative reviews. And to be honest this has to start with *us* - more senior people - who absolutely need to set a good example for new folks
Comments