Excellent points being made and I’m sure everyone can resonate with this experience.
Let’s try to be the reviewer we’d like to have and improve the work we review rather than being antagonistic and trying to find reasons to reject.
Let’s try to be the reviewer we’d like to have and improve the work we review rather than being antagonistic and trying to find reasons to reject.
Reposted from
Laura
To paraphrase Dennett (rip 💔), the goal of reviewing is to determine truth, not to conquer your opponent.
Too many reviewers seem to not have internalised this. In my opinion, this is the hardest lesson a reviewer has to learn, and I want to share some thoughts.
Too many reviewers seem to not have internalised this. In my opinion, this is the hardest lesson a reviewer has to learn, and I want to share some thoughts.
Comments