News Analysis: President Trump’s proposal to transfer millions of people out of Gaza was hailed by the Israeli right and condemned by Palestinians. Some experts say it may be a negotiating tactic.
Comments
Log in with your Bluesky account to leave a comment
OMG stop sane washing this fucking madman. Stop trying to rationalize the bullshit and horrible ideas he spews out of his ass. Call it what it is. The threat of permanent US occupation in the Middle East.
NM the "annexing" of Canada or the taking of Greenland.
Americans have got to see now they are worse off under him. MAGA needs to be declared a terrorist organization worldwide
And the world needs to declare maga a terrorist organization. Economic and physical threats to free nations should qualify it as such. That would be a start
@nytimes.com repeating an unfounded theory by unnamed "experts" while leaving out that this is the definition of #EthnicCleansing, a crime of epic scale, makes your post and headline support the actions being taken. #ReportingGrades
The New York Times is fake news. Trump has fantasies and this is one. It’s not a “negotiating tactic” anymore than your senile grandfather walking outside naked is a “negotiating tactic” for more pudding.
Es posible que los saque como en Vietnam con el tiempo . Los lugareños son una cultura que tiene miles de años desde la época del antiguo testamento . Están comprando un problema como siempre , ojalá mo les salga el tiro por la culata por el bien del dinero de los contribuyentes de USA .
'Some experts' nod and give we at the Times something else appalling to say'.... so if Bibi offers to just eliminate them all, instead, that's a 'win' for Trump...?
Traditionally seen as progressive the NYT melting down to the dictatorship. Like La Vanguardia in Barcelona when Franco’s troops entered the city at the end of the Spanish Civil War.
The US and Israeli government absolutely intend to depopulate Gaza and there is nothing any one can do about it. Certainly not American “progressives”.
If the press hasn’t figured out that trump just likes to hear himself talk then they should be embarrassed. It’s ridiculous that we’re taking him seriously. And start using the words “lie & liar”, instead of “false & untrue”.
It's shocking to me how the population of the United States has normalized playing with the lives of other peoples without ever thinking about the intense pain and suffering caused.
I see it as a tactic to pressure Hamas to release the hostages and disperse. Imagine yourself in the rubble when Israel and the US are on tv talking about developing your neighborhood. And the only time they mention Hamas is when they say Hamas has to go but Palestinians are welcome when its done.
If the US wants to annex Gaza and empty it from the Palestinians why not offer them US citizenship and free entry to the country? Your plan, your problem, your headache.
News Analysis: President Trump’s proposal to transfer millions of people out of Gaza was hailed by the Israeli right and condemned by Palestinians. Some experts say that it reflects President Trump’s delusional racist sadism
Instead of creating a "riviera" for the wealthy, why not help the Palestinians rebuild their homes??? He's such a selfish, heartless creature, and only cares about himself! God help us all 😢
You're complicit in war crimes by justifying it with your cowardly headlines and articles. I hope everyone in your organisation who has contributed to this loses toiler jobs and goes through everything the brave Palestinians have been enduring for decades. This is beyond depraved from MSM.
He doesn't have 'tactics'. He has no plan. He wakes up, smokes an orange crayon, tweets out whatever insane thing comes into his head, and the world collectively asks WTAF?!?
Then Republicans scramble & dodge questions until they can make up a reason to say it's good. The rubes eat it up. The end.
a negotiating tactic?
you don't say NYT?
that's some in-depth analysis!
Is that what they called it in Europe in the mid '30's?
in the future please use more direct and truthful language to describe what it is;
strongman tactics of a fascist with the intent on expanding an "empire"
"Unworkable"?
How about "insane"?
"crazy"?
"delirious"?
"demented"?
"deranged"?
"kooky"?
"nutty"?
"aberrant"?
"bananas"?
"batty"?
"crazed"?
"cuckoo"?
"loony"?
"lunatic"?
"unbalanced"?
"unhinged"?
So many words fit the situation better than "unsound", & those are just the one that are not profane.
NYT has become an unreliable paper. Trump is doing everything he said, his son-in-law thought the land there wonderful for tourism&building, T speaks of a “Riviera”. Who are you fooling?
"Proposal," "plan," and "unworkable" are the most milquetoast vocabulary words you feckless excuses for journalists could possibly use for this ethnic cleansing. NYT, what is WRONG with you? Is anybody on payroll able to be the free press we need right now or are y'all too busy licking Musk's boots?
It started out as one of his stupid ‘jokes’, but now his sick mind thinks it may be worth exploring as there is $$$$$$ to be made. Humanity and peace be damned!
@nytimes.com unworkable? Really? How about completely illegal???? It's a war crime to forcibly remove and relocate people from their sovereign country.
I ♥️the idea of some corn fed Midwest Hogs praising Trump for taking Gaza, when it's those same hogs who have never left their home town that will be sent there to get their legs blown off and their brains scrambled to cleanse an entire people so God emperor can have a tower erected in his name.
Maybe your vast resources could find a definition of ethnic cleansing
You guys are now parodying yourselves.
Tip: look at the headline. Then ask yourself: "Does this look like something from NYTimes Pitchbot?"
If the answer is "yes", as it more and more frequently is, that's ...not good.
not sure what negotiating tactic that will result a positive for Palestinians. result- more radicalization and recruitment for the Palestinians to use more violence.
My God! It's always the same with these people. "Don't get too outraged, he might not mean it. He's just a genius negotiator. Didn't fight him. Let him take over." NYT is effectively Trump propaganda.
Since when did anything that's unfeasible ever stop Trump from proposing it? 2 weeks in and we've already lost track of all the unfeasible proposals he's already made. I assume it's largely for his own amusement, like cheating on the golf course or on his tax returns or grabbing women by the pussy.
What could possibly go wrong? How are fundamentalist Christians reacting? I missed the part in the Bible where it says America will own part of the Holy Land.
No responsible leader would ever say that people now displaced and suffering should illegally move to a foreign country. No expert would ever say that this is a negotiating tactic. Observe that Trump did not offer them citizenship.
Even IF it is actually intended as a “negotiating tactic”, which I have a difficult time believing is actually true given Trump and Netanyahu are involved, we CANNOT normalise threatening ethnic cleansing in order to get a group of people to negotiate.
Hey @nytpitchbot.bsky.social . I’m so sorry that they steal your lines so much of the time now. But I have to say, I’m not sure even you could have come up with using ethnic cleansing as a negotiating tactic.
The NYT delayed reporting on the genocide in WW2. Do not repeat history. Call it what it is: genocide and ethnic cleansing. It is your journalistic duty. Be on the correct side of history.
let’s assume it is a negotiating tactic. (it’s not)It’s one that puts American lives at risk. He just put a target on Americans.
Anyone understanding the history of the Middle East would not negotiate that way. Extremists will have a much easier time getting people to put the vest on.
When you use chaotic rants as your primary diversion tactic while Nazi youth are rooting away in the Treasury databases, you just have to keep escalating. I’m sure threats of nuclear war are coming soon.
After all it’s only American credibility that has been lost.
I too negotiate by threat of genocide. It's a very effective strategy. Well done president. Threaten genocide with an alternative of ethnic cleansing of the region. Super strong and humanitarian negotiating skills. Not fascism or authoritarian at all.
In what possible way could it be a negotiating tactic to give the ethnostate weirdos of the Israeli government everything they want on a silver platter?
Orange buffoon says anything to appease totalitarians. Also repeats the last thing he hears. Benny said something dumb, now it’s a thing while the tariffs fiasco get rolled back.
Since Jordania and Egypt are not taking the people of Gaza, they have to move to USA. And why not, if Gaza becomes a state of USA? They will be USA citizens.
Comments
Americans have got to see now they are worse off under him. MAGA needs to be declared a terrorist organization worldwide
MAGA will never drop him and congressional Republicans are terrified of/aligned with Trump and will let the constitutional crisis continue
Oh, correction. All experts.
Andrew Jackson's Trail of Tears is a direct parallel in our past, and that was "only" 60K people.
Who the fuck are these experts
Calling it a "plan" further normalizes all of his crazy and implies some level of forethought and ability that he does not possess or use.
Looks like the following have rejected the Trump idea of taking over Gaza so far are:
Palestinians, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, Australia , Ireland, China, New Zealand, Germany, Russia, Turkey, and Iran.
https://apnews.com/article/israel-hamas-war-gaza-trump-netanyahu-db2c407baf803291a4acf6edfd708c48
🤦♂️🤦♀️🤦🤦♂️🤦♀️🤦🤦♂️🤦♀️
#FBN #FDJT
Then Republicans scramble & dodge questions until they can make up a reason to say it's good. The rubes eat it up. The end.
you don't say NYT?
that's some in-depth analysis!
Is that what they called it in Europe in the mid '30's?
in the future please use more direct and truthful language to describe what it is;
strongman tactics of a fascist with the intent on expanding an "empire"
How about "insane"?
"crazy"?
"delirious"?
"demented"?
"deranged"?
"kooky"?
"nutty"?
"aberrant"?
"bananas"?
"batty"?
"crazed"?
"cuckoo"?
"loony"?
"lunatic"?
"unbalanced"?
"unhinged"?
So many words fit the situation better than "unsound", & those are just the one that are not profane.
Orange Hitler does EVERYTHING in "It's" power to start world war III for world domination
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/2/5/world-reaction-to-trumps-comments-on-ethnic-cleansing-in-gaza
Stupid plan by a stupid man. Magalamaniac at it again.
IT'S ETHNIC CLEANSING.
Maybe your vast resources could find a definition of ethnic cleansing
You guys are now parodying yourselves.
Tip: look at the headline. Then ask yourself: "Does this look like something from NYTimes Pitchbot?"
If the answer is "yes", as it more and more frequently is, that's ...not good.
You're supposed to be a Fucking News Organisation. Act like one!
Distraction from Musk’s illegal power grab.
And it’s all going to plan.
You keep reporting on him like this is all normal
You can’t just say “deal or genocide”.
Corporate media has failed the American people and abandoned our traditional values.
This should have negotiated him into a psych ward.
JFC.
Anyone understanding the history of the Middle East would not negotiate that way. Extremists will have a much easier time getting people to put the vest on.
After all it’s only American credibility that has been lost.
Fact; Musk has taken over Depts & Musk has access to the United States Treasury. Musk people are in the buildings.
ALL HOUSE AND SENATE REPUBLICANS ARE PART OF THE COUP, MAGA OR NOT.