cdwhite1990.bsky.social
34| I'm a poly, queer He/They content writer from Glasgow who loves #fantasy #dnd #horror and #writing. Follow me for musings on literature and life.
110 posts
610 followers
1,190 following
Regular Contributor
Active Commenter
comment in response to
post
It’s probably that which has led to my career in content writing, my dreams of writing books and my love of D&D.
So, yeah!
I’ll pour one out for The Professor tonight as a thanks for igniting the spark of inspiration that has shaped so much of my creativity.
Thanks Prof
#tolkien #tolkienday
comment in response to
post
I was obsessed with that passage and I pinpoint that as being the moment I fell in love with reading and fantasy.
There is a direct through line of my first experience of Tolkien, to going to university to study Literature and then Fantasy Literature.
Hell, it’s the reason I want to write (…)
comment in response to
post
Books 1-3 of the Horus Heresy have been great! Not without flaw, but, what is?
It’s exactly what I expected and wanted from Warhammer 40k.
I have been pleasantly surprised by the quality of the work by the three authors. Not that I expected the works to be bad…
On to Flight of the Eisenstein
comment in response to
post
I’m giving Galaxy in Flames an 8/10. It was a great read and a great way to bring this arc to a close before we move to Flight of the Eisenstein.
It has made me want more, but, that is largely because I feel that there was more that could be added to this book.
comment in response to
post
Rather than try to correct or refine the clumsy ending of False Gods, Galaxy in Flames moves us along and straight into the action.
There’s not an awful lot of character development beyond separating the goodies and baddies, but it is enough to tantalise us to want to know more.
comment in response to
post
Yes, Ben Counter takes the reins to bring the opening trilogy to a close by providing a quick, action packed story to set the mass of Horus Heresy into action.
Indeed, Galaxy in Flames is the moment the pot boils over and the schemes of chaos are put into devastating effect.
comment in response to
post
I’m already almost through the very short Galaxy in Flames. Listening to audiobooks on 1.5x speed reduced its length to being less than 6hrs. So I’ll be following up with that one, probably tomorrow.
comment in response to
post
I think I would give False Gods a 7/10 score. I think it delivered what it set out to do, but there was certainly some stumbling points, especially in the later chapters of the book.
comment in response to
post
I think McNeill did a great job with this book and was given a difficult and defining moment to write.
Unfortunately this does cause the later third of the book to feel a bit clumsy and heavy handed to move the plot along and hit the story beats.
comment in response to
post
Like I said, I think McNeill had a hard time with this, but did a good job regardless. Whilst I was dismissive of the corruption scene initially, I couldn’t think of a better way to do it myself.
This is by no way a judgement on McNeill’s ability as an author. Quite the contrary.
comment in response to
post
An author is given the task to corrupt the incorruptible and isn’t given a huge amount of space or time in which to do it.
I feel that the author also struggled with this, which is evident during the corruption scenes. Which I feel would go into spoiler territory if I expand on further.
comment in response to
post
Whilst the traitors scheme is very well presented. I felt the execution of the turning point for the series titular character was poorly done and broke my verisimilitude.
Although, in McNeill’s defence, I think this was going to be difficult regardless of what they did.
comment in response to
post
The opening chapters did not grab me the same way Horus Rising did. I first felt this with the Titan crew’s interactions at the start of the novel, which felt out of place and jarring.
The book quickly becomes a competent follow up as the plot develops and the traitors start to play their hand.
comment in response to
post
“BUT WHAT ABOUT HER… LADY BITS?! AND STUFF… Yeah…”
I can’t wait to slay monsters as Ciri! Trailer gave me goosebumps!
comment in response to
post
Horus Rising:
You know you’re getting a franchise book - 40k ✅
It’s a thrilling, easy, linear read ✅
It’s a great introduction to the very complicated and vast lore of the 40k universe ✅
And it’s very tasty! There’s some very memorable moments and cool scenes! It’s a win ✅
A great cheeseburger!
comment in response to
post
I refer to books like this as “cheeseburger books”. You know what you’re getting with a cheeseburger. It’s easy to consume, has wide appeal, and is tasty! It’s not trying to be a “fine dining book” which is a bit more nuanced, complex and has a narrower appeal.
(…)
comment in response to
post
I gave Horus Rising a 9/10. Some may think “oh so this is comparable to the great works of fantasy/Sci-fi out there.”
Well, no, but it is a book that fulfils the brief very well. It knows its audience, genre and setting and leans into that.
(…)
comment in response to
post
Additional note: I listened to this on Audible and Tony Longworth is an AMAZING narrator which certainly helps!
comment in response to
post
Which can feel a little disappointing. Yet, I couldn’t wait to sink my teeth into book 2 - False Gods by Graham McNeill.
Overall a cracking read and a great introduction to 40k for me, I’m invested and look forward to reading more Abnett as the Horus Heresy continues.
9/10
comment in response to
post
In that it really is a novel length introduction to the series and although some intrigue and curiosity is raised (and keeps the pages turning), it never really goes beyond that and we are left without a satisfactory conclusion with questions being answered… that’s saved for future books (…)
comment in response to
post
The book is very approachable to newcomers to the 40k universe, I found it very readable and not without nuance and skill from a very talented author.
The book suffers by its concept, in that it is the first of an ENORMOUS series of books which will encompass different authors (…)
comment in response to
post
Wind and Truth by Brandon Sanderson. He’s my current favourite author outside of some classics, like Tolkien, le Guin etc.
comment in response to
post
Whilst he definitely hasn't gotten rich in terms of monitary gain. He has gone from unwanted bastard child to a noble position.
Maybe I'll have a different opinion by the time I finish. Part way through chapter 17 at this point.
comment in response to
post
That's totally fair! I liked it cause it was new for me. It's actually something I'm struggling with in my own writing. Magic is a big deal, but I feel there's an expectation to explain how magic works in your world... Rather than, magic just exists.
comment in response to
post
A new one the scene author would struggle to sell a Stormlight Archive as their first book.
It meanders, it's tangential, it switches viewpoints a lot and there's lots of detailed characters to keep in mind.
But, man, when those emotional or action-packed scenes hit. They hit hard!
comment in response to
post
As much as I love Stormlight, I totally understand why people don't. The books are intimidating and often slow. Sanderson himself has said that he gets away with going on the tangents in the book, because his audience (the ones that love his stuff) trust him as an author, and so do the publishers.
comment in response to
post
And that's totally ok and valid! 😁 I bet there's stuff out there we do match on!
Like I say, I am enjoying the book enough to finish it, but whether I finish the trilogy is another story.
comment in response to
post
I did like Malazan! I found the world in The Malazan books interesting enough to keep me entertained. Farseer trilogy is less intriguing to me.
comment in response to
post
Thoughts? How forgiving are you of a book you're not enjoying if you've heard that a book further in the series "is where it gets good"?
comment in response to
post
This has been my issue getting into books such as #TheWheelofTime. I read the first one and found it quite boring.
But those who love the series are often like "oh, wait until THIS part". They are then disgusted when I tell them I probably won't get there.