Profile avatar
chrisedelson.bsky.social
Assistant professor of government at American University. Area of focus: US presidential power and authoritarian threats to democracy. Writing a book on emergency presidential power in context of Trump. https://www.american.edu/spa/faculty/edelson.cfm
1,666 posts 1,109 followers 573 following
Prolific Poster
Conversation Starter

When a cabinet member announces "We are using the military to liberate an American city from its elected leaders," where do you go from there. What is left to say. The idea of that being anything short of a near-universal "Wait, what the fuck is going on" moment proves how far we've backslid.

A few observations about where we are right now: The Trump administration is clearly targeting Democratic politicians through arrests and repression. This rightfully scares academics like myself who have seen this movie play out in other countries (Ukraine, Turkey, etc.). It doesn’t end well.

I will continue to hold my deeply unpopular belief that Harris/Walz narrowly win if GWB & Mitt Romney endorse & campaign for them in October 2024. At the very least, both of them should be out now, in front of every microphone they can find, condemning the fascism & calling for Trump's removal.

Just going to put this here, for a variety of reasons, including what GWB said & so that we never have to have a National Conversation™️ about wHiCh pArTy hAs MoVeD fURtHeR frOm tHe PoLiTiCaL CenTeR iN tHe 21st CeNTuRy ever again.

Because Black people know that there is no such thing as “identification” or “identifying yourself”. They aren’t saying Padilla didn’t identify himself as a U.S. Senator. They are saying that there is only one acceptable identity — credential — being white and, in these times, being pro-Trump.

Every elected Republican should be asked if they think the president has the power to send in military in to “liberate” a state or city from its elected government.

noem should resign or be impeached

We drill into military officers that Members of Congress have Constitutional oversight rights, Members outrank four-stars in protocol, and even Congressional staffers are treated like generals/admirals. To see sworn federal officers manhandle and handcuff a U.S. Senator... I'm still shook up.

We are marching to Senator Thune’s office. There must be accountability for the detainment of a Senator. This is not normal.

What happened to Senator Padilla is not homeland security. This is homeland fascism. This is homeland authoritarianism.

Another video of Senator Padilla’s violent arrest at DHS Sec Noem’s press conference in LA. You can see him thrown to the ground by FBI agents and handcuffed. (video shared by Padilla’s staff with Elex Michaelson of Fox LA and posted on X)

In Donald Trump's America, if you say "I am Senator Alex Padilla, I have questions for the Secretary," you get thrown to the floor and handcuffed.

imagine, if one can, if Lindsey Graham or Ted Cruz or Tom Cotton tried to ask a question to a Biden admin cabinet secy and had been forced to the ground and handcuffed by federal agents.

In the past week, a union leader has been arrested, a U.S. Rep charged with a crime, a U.S. Senator violently handcuffed, and reporters shot with rubber bullets and detained. There is no ambiguity. This is a regime operating as an authoritarian. Americans who believe in liberty must oppose it.

Donald Trump promised that any protests of his military parade will be met with "very heavy" force. Democracy is under attack.

authoritarianism is a word that works well for scholars. What we're seeing is perhaps better described as aspiring dictatorship or fascism.

What will you do when authoritarianism comes to America? Because it's here. Right now.

Senator Alex Padilla is one of the most decent people I know. This is outrageous, dictatorial, and shameful. Trump and his shock troops are out of control. This must end now.

This is a US Senator, one of two representing nearly 40 million people from nation's most productive, populous, and *tax paying* state, being physically roughed up by goons at behest of deranged president and out of control cabinet secretary. HEY GOP SENATORS. You'll swallow even this?

The strategy is to do your Constitutionally-approved job and make them stop you. Make them show the world that they violate the Constitution. Make them show where they draw the lines and how they want to exercise power.

Holy shit. This is @padilla.senate.gov They just forcibly arrested a U.S. Senator.

What would you say if you saw it in another country? A senator from a coequal branch of government dragged away by security from asking a question of a Cabinet official

Ok. I don’t know how many alarms this is. It’s all of them.

One thing we didn’t touch on: If Trump gets away with this, he will absolutely do the same thing during the 2026 & 2028 elections. He will manufacture unrest just like in LA and send federal troops to every major city as a way to intimidate voters and decrease turnout. Functional end to fair elex.

From my undergraduate lecture notes on the Weimar Republic's collapse

This is correct. There is nothing complicated about it. You either see what is going on and condemn it, or you make excuses for despotism.

"we're not cool with fascism" is a pretty good way to describe opposition to trump

You go through your whole life listening to big people talk up what they'd totally do should some obviously, cartoonishly evil threat arise in their time, but when the time comes, the biggest talkers just look around like "gosh, I hope somebody does something about that."

God he’s such an idiot. A black hole of pure ignorance.

New AP poll, Trump is at -21 approval with more than twice as many Americans strongly disapproving (41) to strongly approving (20). Trump is wildly unpopular despite a relatively strong economic tailwind and other favorable conditions. Americans don't like dictators. apnorc.org/projects/mos...

Thanks to @defenseone.bsky.social for publishing my latest on the military’s norm of nonpartisanship and why Army leaders must uphold and teach this, now more than ever. www.defenseone.com/ideas/2025/0...

trump thinks the US military--indeed, the entire US government--belongs to him and is offended when anyone suggests otherwise. What an astounding act of national self-destruction to allow him access to power.

Must read. Incredible and thoughtful first-person account. Surprisingly, the most shocking part is not journalists and college professors being arrested. It’s police trapping the crowd—giving a disperse order while blocking all the exits. via @smotus.bsky.social smotus.substack.com/p/arrested-i...

The president of the United States in our time is not supposed to wield armed troops and even station marines on American soil because of political speech and assembly he doesn’t like, that is typically not allowed and no I don’t care if any of it is technically “legal”

“The sentiment across the board right now is that deploying military force against our own communities isn’t the kind of national security we signed up for,” said Sarah Streyder of the Secure Families Initiative..." www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025...

“In a democratic society, citizens don’t have to think twice...about peaceful expressions of opposition — that’s what life is like in a free society,” Levitsky said. "In an authoritarian regime, citizens have to think twice about speaking out, bc there is risk of government retribution" (Wa Post)

It’s completely insane that US troops are illegally deployed to suppress domestic opposition and it’s not uniformly condemned by the press and political elite.

Sun sets on an unraveling country where military has started entering major cities & a Soviet style tank parade will take over the Capitol in 2 days. The President may have given tacit approval for a hit on Iran’s nuclear centers. Yet these Yankees seem dazed, arguing baseball and Benson Boone.