kieranholly.bsky.social
MA by research at University of Huddersfield
Supporter of Grimsby Town and write about cricket
32 posts
27 followers
67 following
Getting Started
Active Commenter
comment in response to
post
21/ Is sustaining the game, never mind growing it, going to be productive if we exclude fans from the outset?
comment in response to
post
20/ domestic cricket because from it’s early inception it didn’t try to gatekeep the game. We can either accept that this is the way it will be forever or we have to work collectively to undo the structures that have made it this way.
comment in response to
post
19/ regularly invest in outside of international cricket, which there currently isn’t. As long as people advocate for everything to just stay the same, cricket will remain stagnant at best or continue declining. Cricket in Aus generates scenes like this and interest in
comment in response to
post
18/ T20, but there is still a vilification of fans drinking too much and behaving inappropriatey. If you want domestic cricket to be of interest to the wider public and grow the game, it needs to be visible, which it currently isn’t, and there needs to be something to
comment in response to
post
17/ was formed as a fan group that performs in opposition to the established values within English cricket, but this is focused entirely towards the national team. The only level of domestic cricket that generates an alternative performance in domestic cricket is
comment in response to
post
16/ That’s not to say that fans of domestic cricket don’t have passion, but it’s exhibited in a different way because of how cricket fandom in England has been established and the social class of people that watch domestic cricket. The Barmy Army
comment in response to
post
15/ English cricket is not set up to grow the fanbase but instead to extract from the existing fanbase. Circling back to my question of why is Australia the exception, cricket is not supported by anyone who would behave like the scenes we've all enjoyed viewing.
comment in response to
post
14/ it's because of the strong club scene and the strength of the pyramid. In the absence of free-to-air cricket, fans outside the FCCs have nothing to invest in and inevitably drop away between international fixtures. The way to sustain fandom is regularity in investment.
comment in response to
post
13/ is essentially geared towards this fetishisation of the Ashes because of the money it brings in and the interest generated from non-traditional cricket fans. It's essentially a brand. When you think about the strength of football in Eng, it’s not because of the national team,
comment in response to
post
12/ Thirdly is the general sport culture within Eng. I don’t think the way English cricket is set up is adequate in growing the game here. English domestic cricket is essentially for members of the counties and a vehicle for the national team, and the national team
comment in response to
post
11/ existing fanbase. There are TV programmes showing football and rugby highlights, is there any effort from either the counties or ECB to get a county cricket highlights show on BBC/ITV etc? It seems like domestic cricket is just happy to exist in a vacuum.
comment in response to
post
10/ If cricket isn’t visible, then it’s not going to generate a wider interest. It’s great that many of the county teams now have free livestreams, but unless there’s any effort to promote them among non-traditional cricket fans, they’re only really there to service the
comment in response to
post
9/ These examples were at a time when cricket was free on TV and was much more prevalent in the public consciousness. It’s no coincidence that cricket hasn’t generated the same level of interest among the wider public since it moved to Sky and other subscription services.
comment in response to
post
8/ Instruments had been banned from venues in an effort to curb their method of support. There is an acceptable way to spectate cricket, and these examples do not fall into that remit. Secondly, there just isn’t the same level of access to cricket in Eng that there once was.
comment in response to
post
7/ community following. A lot of people have said the scenes in Aus remind them of scenes here in the 70s and 80s. I also want to highlight that whilst many people reminisce about the West Indies support in England during the 70s and 80s, they were often vilified at the time.
comment in response to
post
6/ just being a bit loud and having a laugh. I’ve also spent a lot of time in Huddersfield which has a strong cricket culture where class isn’t as relevant compared to other parts of the country. The same sort of behaviour isn’t uncommon and the clubs have much more of a
comment in response to
post
5/ a decent midweek cricket league. A couple of people I went to school with play for team of essentially footy lads who play cricket in the summer and one was telling me that they often piss off other teams because of their behaviour which is basically
comment in response to
post
4/ Whilst we had scenes of MCC members hurling abuse at Aus, Strauss was on comms saying the atmosphere was down to cheaper tickets attracting 'people who don’t usually come to lords'. This also goes down to grassroots level. Grimsby is a very working-class town but has
comment in response to
post
3/ loutish and ill-mannered and called for vocal young men to be caned. This pretty much demonstrates the dynamics of how cricket culture has developed in Eng and how cricket should be supported. You can see the repercussions of this today. Think back to the last Ashes at Lords.
comment in response to
post
2/ the whole of the country. Urban and rural areas, and regardless of social class, going back to the 19th century. This is in stark contrast to the cricket culture in England. Plum Warner, who led England in the 1903-04 Ashes series, called the Australian supporters
comment in response to
post
Can I ask what this was in reference to? I'm at work so not watching the game
comment in response to
post
Sadly I couldn't make the CRN this year but will look for the podcast. Similarly with international cricket a lot of the associates have targeted the women's team as the vehicle for growth because the ceiling is far higher than in the men's. Just look at the progress made by Thailand Brazil etc
comment in response to
post
It's not about sustaining a professional setup they already play the games in the NCCA it's about integrating it. Lincoln are never gonna win the Premier League but they're in a system where they can build towards it. If we can't build a fully representative T20 league then there is no hope
comment in response to
post
I can't help but feel you've missed the point. If I was born in Sheffield I would support Yorkshire. Cricket fans outside FCCs take day trips to Scarborough, Headingley, Trent Bridge etc. Everyone needs to be represented so fans can turn sporadic engagement into a long term and sustained investment.
comment in response to
post
I do refer to men's cricket as the women's regional system has been reformed with the three tier system and knockout comp. I would advocate for promotion and relegation in a nation-wide T20 Blast but understand why this isn't being considered in the women's structure until 2028
comment in response to
post
Thank you for sharing Andrew I really value your backing on this issue
comment in response to
post
Thank you for sharing
comment in response to
post
Brill thank you!
comment in response to
post
Is anything from the event going to be uploaded onto the YouTube channel?