stevenpmillies.com
professor | author | political theorist | ersatz theologian | Chicago southsider | bylines National Catholic Reporter, The Hill, The Conversation (AP), Religion News Service, others | "great work on behalf of normality" | personal account
1,549 posts
2,012 followers
4,514 following
Regular Contributor
Active Commenter
comment in response to
post
It was our job to use them correctly.
comment in response to
post
They did anticipate parties.
They warned us about them, and how party government would reward a despot.
comment in response to
post
Spending just a little time reading them would reveal how precarious they knew the system was because they entrusted it to the people.
We failed, not the system.
comment in response to
post
It's the whole darned shootin' match.
comment in response to
post
Agreeing its almost an entirely they-wont-come-to-us problem, still some characterizations of them are a kind of unwelcoming.
Open hearts, open arms.
comment in response to
post
And.
*Anyone* unwilling to welcome the "Catholic traditionalists" who in good faith want to share the Church with the rest of us since May 8 also doesn't comprehend how fundamentally the situation has changed.
comment in response to
post
John Ganz wrote this after October 7 and I keep coming back to it.
www.unpopularfront.news/p/the-trap
comment in response to
post
comment in response to
post
comment in response to
post
comment in response to
post
comment in response to
post
I'm the wrong guy to ask.
I'd drain the word influencer out of English today if I could. It's too compromised by attention-seeking and monetization. It's not helping.
comment in response to
post
Not the ballpark.
comment in response to
post
...there are priests and bishops for whom it's not true. And the difference isn't difficult to see.
Some work is in order to highlight that.
comment in response to
post
Its a tricky business, the academic-vs-normie Catholic divide. I get the criticism. But also, you and I are trustworthy *because* we will never get rich doing this, we serve institutions, we have media presence but aren't building media empires. There are academic for whom that's not true, much...
comment in response to
post
...a marketing differentiator, something intended to segment (or, divide) people. Cultivating Catholicism as a brand scandalizes me, particularly when it is brand-building that can be monetized. All the more when it is done wearing a habit or a Roman collar.
comment in response to
post
...as a grave matter. It is the teaching of Jesus on adultery. Also I called my father father (or some variation thereof) every day (Mt 23:9). Guessing Fr Schmitz is equally guilty of that.
And my point is just to highlight that it is dangerous when Catholicism becomes...
comment in response to
post
...incompatible that we should have no relationship at all, apparently even if we are siblings.
Both the Catechism and canon law are silent on the specifics of this question and so you have to ask why so much energy gets expended on a 10min video that insists this is something we should regard...
comment in response to
post
...(2) the 'your relationship is bigger than one day' argument is scandalously specious, its premise that 'you must respect my beliefs' is false when it claims 'I respect your beliefs' but I must decline your invitation because your beliefs are sinful. Really its an argument that we are so...
comment in response to
post
Hell, I seem to be getting there for nodding yes at the Code of Canon Law.
comment in response to
post
This you, extreme Catholic lefty?
news.nd.edu/news/student...
comment in response to
post
...platform in 2025. But he has also inadvertently volunteered the reason so many of us he dismisses as "left" or "woke" find his online presence so worrying.
comment in response to
post
...both the unity of the whole Church as much as to "all the Christian faithful," and he is to "extend his apostolic spirit to those who...no longer practice their religion." Everyone, without distinction.
If he takes "delight[]" in divisions, that seems like a good way to run a lucrative online...