FWIW, I'm not dogmatic about peer review. After all, Bahar made the same error last year in a "peer-reviewed" journal article (and perhaps other work) and that definitely should have been caught.
That kind of "peer review" should not be the end of the process. Replication is generally undervalued
Comments
That kind of "peer review" should not be the end of the process. Replication is generally undervalued