Mushroom zombies are significantly more plausible than a bunch of randoms finding a cure for mushroom zombies by poking around in one innocent girls brain in a dirty abandoned hospital.
the most logical and scientific argument i've ever read, personally. it's a made up virus in a made up universe, you can't speak to how it works or what would cure it
Okay but thats just putting your thumb on the scales. I agree that realistically the last thing you'd want to do was kill the one immune person but at that point you have no moral dilemma. Joel is correct cause the fireflies are dumb not because of whatever fatherhood statement.
Actually, the alternative is BOTH sides waited a few hours for her to wake up and allow her to make the decisions for herself.
Both sides were certain if they did that, she'd choose "wrong" and the tragedy is that them being certain of this is exactly why the only moral choice is to wait.
Any other choice is predicated on the idea that it doesn't matter what Ellie would do for herself, that only her pseudo parent figures have the right to make the call.
if you take everything at face value. if was the real world they would kill her just to have material for study and testing with no real cure guarantee and if they find it they are never going to be able to mass produce it. could be intentional or could be bad writing we are never going to know.
Comments
What's the point of the world if the person I love by far the most isn't part of it
Both sides were certain if they did that, she'd choose "wrong" and the tragedy is that them being certain of this is exactly why the only moral choice is to wait.