3D version of yesterday's farm scene. Do you prefer this or the pixel art style? - ThreadSky

friedemanna.bsky.social • 210 days ago

3D version of yesterday's farm scene. Do you prefer this or the pixel art style?

Comments

rascarcapackdev.com•210 days ago

I prefer this one ! except for the character, the pixel one looks pretty cool

bengreensmith.bsky.social•209 days ago

I do love pixel art but have to admit I much prefer the 3D one in this case. It would be interesting to see the 3D one with the windmill as I think elements like that would sell it even more.

olau.eyosido.com•209 days ago

Both are actually great! How do you go from one to the other though, reducing the texture resolution?

friedemanna.bsky.social•209 days ago

They are completely separate projects with their own assets actually. I rebuilt the scene twice in order to make a decision between the two styles :)

vltmn.itch.io•209 days ago

I'd go for this 3D setup but perhaps with a more stylized (half-lambert?) lighting style! Whatever you choose it looks great, I love seeing this little greenhouse 💚

friedemanna.bsky.social•209 days ago

Thanks Flo! It's modelled after my grandma's greenhouse, so it's funny you'd call this out specifically <3

What is it about half-lambert that you think would work better here? I've never consciously used that type of lighting I think.

moczan.com•210 days ago

I'm already attached to the uncle so definitely this one

friedemanna.bsky.social•209 days ago

hahaha, gonna call him the uncle from here on out

hugobdesigner.bsky.social•210 days ago

I think I prefer this. It's stylized enough on its own, and looks quite unique :)

friedemanna.bsky.social•209 days ago

Thanks! Yeah I'm with you I think.

ruthbosch.bsky.social•209 days ago

This one is sooo much nicer I love it!

drshakspere.bsky.social•208 days ago

So this one looks very good

timonpoika.bsky.social•210 days ago

this absolutely!

danwhitehead.net•209 days ago

I think the 3D one looks more tactile and inviting.

neurisko.bsky.social•210 days ago

It's hard to really say, they both get crushed by the upload process.

friedemanna.bsky.social•209 days ago

yeah I only noticed today how bad it actually is. Is there like a secret trick for uploading that makes the quality better?

neurisko.bsky.social•209 days ago

Not sure, video on bsky is relatively new. Maybe just upload to YouTube in HQ and then post a link? It might just embed it.

friedemanna.bsky.social•209 days ago

Good shout! will try that next

rickyhaggett.bsky.social•210 days ago

they're both lovely, but I think maybe this one? The video compression here makes it hard to make a proper call through.

friedemanna.bsky.social•209 days ago

yeah it's so bad, is there a trick to make it better somehow?

rickyhaggett.bsky.social•209 days ago

Nah. In their last update, they talked about a future plan for premium accounts which would be able to post bigger files.

synesthetician.bsky.social•210 days ago

Can I move in immediately? My dog and I will be good tenants🥺🙏

mattendo.bsky.social•209 days ago

Tough call, both styles are really good looking. I think this 3D version is my preferred one

xdarkshadow1stx.bsky.social•210 days ago

You know this might sound crazy but you could have a filter to where you give it the option of both. I prefer the pixel but I could definitely see the 3D doing well

riverforge.bsky.social•210 days ago

They are both awesome! I prefer the pixel art style.

samsonarx.bsky.social•210 days ago

For me, it's 2D. It looks more stylized and original

Comments

Posting Rules

Reply