This guy thinks "smart policy" is not cancelling all student debt, a unilateral power the executive possesses requiring no journey through the legislature, and instead instead colluding with the GOP to *restart payments* What a Heroic Realist! ❤️ - ThreadSky

hayao.lol • 526 days ago

This guy thinks "smart policy" is not cancelling all student debt, a unilateral power the executive possesses requiring no journey through the legislature, and instead instead colluding with the GOP to *restart payments*

What a Heroic Realist! ❤️

Comments

alexanderthemeh.bsky.social•526 days ago

They've formed parasocial relationships with people who do the bidding of and have taken millions of dollars from other people who have billions of dollars. Like everything he's said is
1)factually wrong
But more importantly
2)exactly what Biden admin put out to say.
He's a dumb parrot.

daveanthony.bsky.social•526 days ago

These are the instant block people go me.

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•526 days ago

Yup. As @aacoek.bsky.social stated, self-care is important.

sdfrankowski.bsky.social•526 days ago

Lol. Da fuck are u talking about? I’m just someone with more student debt than all u fuckers who follows the topic closely for both personal and professional reasons. But yes, u are the expert, Mr Meh.

sdfrankowski.bsky.social•526 days ago

Smart policy is policy that can be enacted.

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•526 days ago

Dude, he can simply cancel fucking all of the debt. Would it be held up somewhere by shithead politicians and bureaucrats? Probably, but when the fuck has that stopped anyone? It would be a massively good move for popularity, it would flood local economy with $s.

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•526 days ago

He took the difficult road to appease the GOP, who took it to SCOTUS, which is filled with fascists, and he rolled over because he wants money more than votes. I have $75k in student debt and have been hamstrung at every turn by the public service act. Now I make too much to get relief.

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•526 days ago

When I was making less than $22k a year, there were NO programs for me and I had to defer payments, thus negating my chance to qualify for the PSFL. There are millions of me out there. You going so hard for this skim milk answer to a festering national wound is being a puppet for The Fat Cats (R).

sdfrankowski.bsky.social•525 days ago

But part of what rules change did was give retroactive credit for pslf even during pandemic deferment. The pslf program was utterly fucked for years and now actually works.

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•525 days ago

No, it doesn’t work well. I’m here to tell you - my 17 years in nonprofit still do not count because I didn’t make enough payments and now I make too much to qualify. It’s fine for me in the grand scheme, but it’s a shit solution.

amancuso.bsky.social•526 days ago

If the government is going to give away massive piles of cash, why should the money go to indebted college students and not, say, impoverished parents or any number of other people in need?

vegetablegremlin.bsky.social•526 days ago

It is fun to look at how many things you get wrong in this post.

catticus.bsky.social•526 days ago

porque no los dos?

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•526 days ago

Also, your response smacks of educlassism. You think all ppl who have college debt graduated and got fancy degrees? For profit schools gave cosmetology students overpriced loans and many of those folks are super vulnerable. That’s just one example. Other people had to drop out. Still have debt.

amancuso.bsky.social•525 days ago

I know you're passionate and informed about this, which is why I asked the question. I'm genuinely interested in your answer and would love more info on the study you mentioned. I'm still not convinced we wouldn't be better off simply targeting such people directly though.

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•525 days ago

And to your other point: I agree that we should be taking money and putting it directly into the wallets of people who are very poor. I would actually prefer that.

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•525 days ago

It wasn’t a study - more like one of many articles and concepts that outlines how student loan forgiveness is beneficial to marginalized communities. My bad. https://theappeal.org/the-lab/research/the-case-for-cancelling-student-debt/

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•526 days ago

Here’s a thought: indebted college students are ALSO impoverished parents and other people in need!

A study came out that said the biggest group of people who would benefit from student debt cancellation would be LMI Black people.

ourania.bsky.social•526 days ago

This is not an either/or thing. You can help one group of people without being precluded from helping another.

hayao.lol•526 days ago

I'll pretend this is an earnest question and you're a person worth engaging- because he specifically has complete power over student loan debt and can cancel it by presidential fiat without requiring the cooperation of any other branch of government

willkeats.bsky.social•526 days ago

not to dive in but Biden did try that and the Supreme Court made up some REAL bullshit using the so called 'major questions doctrine' and overturned his first attempt at student loan forgiveness

agirlnamedfritz.bsky.social•525 days ago

To that, I would say to Biden: Try, try again. Just do it. Use the power you have to do something of historic proportion. Hang it up in courts again, fine, whatever. Give SCOTUS something else to rule on. Work. For. Us.

hayao.lol•525 days ago

and he ignored them and erased some anyway

the executive in this country can do pretty much whatever it wants after decades of right wing power creep and lack of dem pushback, the problem is only the GOP uses it agressively

amancuso.bsky.social•525 days ago

That's a reasonable answer; I appreciate it. Obviously nothing is passing congress anytime soon. I will admit that I'd hoped for a little more benefit of the doubt around here than the trollfest of the other place.

wildheart-baby.bsky.social•525 days ago

Maybe they could fund it from the trillions they spend on the military.

sdfrankowski.bsky.social•525 days ago

Congress absolutely should

msp.themsp.org•525 days ago

why not both? do you not know how money works in the U.S.?

sdfrankowski.bsky.social•526 days ago

I am all for it if it’s possible, but I agree, politicians would bring suit and I don’t see scotus ruling differently. What we have instead is a policy that is allowed under current law and effectively does erase debt for poor ppl and substantially reduce it for middle to high income earners.

Comments

Posting Rules

Reply