ThreadSky
About ThreadSky
Log In
deeesharp.bsky.social
•
495 days ago
Hey Philsky! What are the best critiques you’ve read of rights forfeiture theories of punishment? (Also open to good defenses if need be).
Comments
Log in
with your Bluesky account to leave a comment
[–]
dweltman.bsky.social
•
495 days ago
No good account of which rights are forfeited and why.
0
1
reply
[–]
deeesharp.bsky.social
•
495 days ago
Totally agree! (And this is the central thing I need to claim in a paper).
0
1
reply
[–]
deeesharp.bsky.social
•
494 days ago
Do you know any paper that makes this point well?
0
1
reply
[–]
dweltman.bsky.social
•
494 days ago
Not off the top of my head unfortunately. Wellman probably discusses it in the book.
1
1
reply
[–]
dweltman.bsky.social
•
494 days ago
Also this:
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-11874-6_14
0
1
reply
[–]
deeesharp.bsky.social
•
494 days ago
Thanks!
0
reply
[–]
happyspastic.bsky.social
•
495 days ago
Richard Dagger’s “fair play” theory of punishment is thought provoking if, ultimately, flawed.
1
reply
Posting Rules
Be respectful to others
No spam or self-promotion
Stay on topic
Follow Bluesky's terms of service
×
Reply
Post Reply
Comments