With all the P4 remake talks today, I’m wondering if they’re gonna use og or Golden as the base. Also if they do another English VA overhaul for the remake fans aren’t gonna take it well 😶😶
Comments
Log in with your Bluesky account to leave a comment
Who knows on the VA department. I don’t see why P4 would need recasts but maybe to keep in line with P3R they would. The original cast is iconic so if things do change it’s gonna take getting used too
It also would feel like an inferior version honestly, like you get a remake but its of the og which is missing lots of important story context. Why pay 70 for that when Golden is dirt cheap and has a complete story?
I imagine they'd use Golden, though it's partly me wanting Marie to be in if they do make it.
I hope they'd keep the current cast and just recast Rise VA (i.e. Alexis Tipton) since they can't use Laura/Ashly, instead of EVERYONE. I don't know why P3R did that despite the OG cast being IN THE GAME.
Also, I really don't for one second believe that they decided it'd be easier for P3R to "recast everybody" instead of just recasting Junpei. That doesn't feel like it'd make rational sense.
Not using Golden would be incredibly dumb. It isn't like Persona 3, where Fem Avatar was optional and meant writing the game twice, or FES, whose epilogue story mode was a foreseeable DLC.
Not using Golden would be like re-releasing Persona 5 for Switch 2 and PS6 without Royal content.
Yeah like JYB and Yuri not being there for Yu, Yosuke, and Adachi would be jarring for sure. Reload worked out nicely for the most part so we’d just have to wait and see who’s casted for them
i just hope whoever does the voice over will be doing a good job
personally, im not planning to buy the p4 remake, so it wont be of any consequence but for those who do, i want them to have their best experience
Comments
personally i think it's pointless w/ p4g on everything & with everything you could ask for in p4g
(idrc for remakes in general, it's usually saved money for me)
I hope they'd keep the current cast and just recast Rise VA (i.e. Alexis Tipton) since they can't use Laura/Ashly, instead of EVERYONE. I don't know why P3R did that despite the OG cast being IN THE GAME.
Not using Golden would be like re-releasing Persona 5 for Switch 2 and PS6 without Royal content.
If they did that incredibly stupid movement: it would be like choosing the prettier game in comparison to the most complete game.
And it isn't like finishing P3R, buying Portable for Steam and then replaying it with the fem avatar.
VA wise, I’m expecting the same as Reload, which is gonna be both cool and weird given how iconic some VAs are for the characters they reprise
personally, im not planning to buy the p4 remake, so it wont be of any consequence but for those who do, i want them to have their best experience