@dgalasinski.bsky.social oh, how disappointing, we disagree. I have left a comment. I admit, we could disagree because I am the least typical wine buyer in the world. But I really think I disagree because of what you have said in the past and my views of a merchants' duty when writing neck labels. - ThreadSky

elitistreview.com • 5 hours ago

@dgalasinski.bsky.social oh, how disappointing, we disagree. I have left a comment.

I admit, we could disagree because I am the least typical wine buyer in the world. But I really think I disagree because of what you have said in the past and my views of a merchants' duty when writing neck labels.

Comments

dgalasinski.bsky.social•5 hours ago

We agree more than you think. You must not set yourself as a reference. But I recently came across aleatico. I like local varieties but knew nothing abt producer or grape and was in shop. How do I make even a semblance of choice if the wine is fairly pricey. I’m afraid a score offers a crutch.

dgalasinski.bsky.social•5 hours ago

I used to be dead against scores for all reasons Simon Woolf offered. I am much more ambivalent and less ready to be all or nothing.

elitistreview.com•4 hours ago

That's fair comment. I shouldn't be black and white. I suppose I just dislike the abjuration of responsibility of picking the highest score without bothering to engage more. But, as we've said a lot, I'm not remotely typical - I have time and a desire to connect.

dgalasinski.bsky.social•4 hours ago

Yes. I have wine drinking neighbours. Scores would change their life tbh. Atm they simply take ‚deals’. And I aleays take my own wine when visiting :)

elitistreview.com•4 hours ago

Hahaha! But they are possibly not looking for quality wine, just a cheap(er) drink. Take your own wine.

It is both ultimately wonderful but also peevishly irritating when an argument ends in total agreement!😉😆😆😆😆

elitistreview.com•5 hours ago

I find it a very nebulous crutch. I'd rather have a story. I've worked in bookshops and wineshops, I made sure I knew my charges well. I think that's a duty of someone trying to take your cash for any item.

But you are right to say I'm no example.

dgalasinski.bsky.social•4 hours ago

We agree. I’d rather have a compenent merchant telling me abt wine. But they’re latgely unavailable. So unless you want to do a quick read from Wines of Italy, you’re left with the nebulous crutch. What’s crucial is that one understands it’s nebulous and not an objective assessment.

elitistreview.com•4 hours ago

Fair enough! I'll go with that.

Comments

Posting Rules

Reply