msoskil.bsky.social
Science Teacher ~ Unionist ~ University Lecturer ~ Author ~ Hiker ~ 2018 PA Teacher of the Year ~ 2016 GTP Top 10 ~ PAEMST ~ National Parks Supporter ~ Editor of http://FlipTheSystem.US ~ Trying to leave the world better than I found it. #edusky
245 posts
5,227 followers
1,662 following
Regular Contributor
Active Commenter
comment in response to
post
This decision to dismantle the US Department of Education was never about educational achievement. It was always about removing equal opportunity for all children. 14/14
comment in response to
post
The USDoEd doesn't set curriculum. It doesn't tell teachers how to teach. It helps provide equal opportunity for all kids. Which is exactly why it's being shut down. If you examine the words the administration banned from federal websites & research studies, "equal opportunity" is on the list. 13/
comment in response to
post
By ignoring the full USDoEd mission including equal opportunity and removing that oversight, some states are once again able to ensure rural, poor, and students w/ disabilities and communities will never get what they need to be successful. 12/
comment in response to
post
Kids in rural and poor were not given an opportunity to succeed. Additionally, children with disabilities were ignored in some states. The US DoEd's mission was to help those schools and those kids have the opportunity to be successful. That is now in danger. 11/
comment in response to
post
As a country, we have far more income inequality and children living in poverty than almost any other developed country measured by PISA tests. The USDoEd was created in part because some states refused to fund rural schools and schools in poor areas equally. 10/
comment in response to
post
Finally, to your point of the US Department of Education's mission - if you read it, it's not just about student achievement. It also explicitly mentions global competitiveness and equal access to education. 9/
comment in response to
post
And, it's also worth noting that the President recently signed executive orders dismantling the little data privacy protection we had. So, this will likely worsen in the age of Generative AI. 8/
comment in response to
post
It's worth noting at this point that other countries, especially in Europe, have much stronger data privacy laws than the US has, and this has protected students in those countries more than here. 7/
comment in response to
post
I'm really good at what I do, but it's hard to compete with algorithms designed to tap into your inner psychology and make you addicted to a screen. 6/
comment in response to
post
It's addictive. We see many kids spending hours per day doom scrolling on Tik Tok, Instagram, etc. Adults aren't immune - you probably found this post during your daily FB scrolling. As kids got addicted to the dopamine hit from scrolling SM, they became more difficult to motivate in school. 5/
comment in response to
post
What’s been happening in the same time period (namely about 2017 to now)? Predictive AI being used in social media. Around that time, accelerated by the pandemic, students and others have been subject to SM algorithms designed to keep you consuming social media so that companies can profit. 4/
comment in response to
post
It is true that on the NAEP, a test used internally in the US to measure student educational progress, scores have declined sharply since the pandemic. I've seen this used as justification to attack USDoEd as well. Let's explore that, since it somewhat correlates with the decline in math scores. 3/
comment in response to
post
In fact, on the international PISA test used to compare ed systems, in 2022, US reading scores were 6th in the world -among our highest ever. We were 10th in science. But, math scores showed a sharp decline. This decline was consistent with other countries as well. This ties into a second point. 2/
comment in response to
post
There are plenty more differences, and I'm all for trying to better our education system to be more like other countries that outperform us. I am pretty confident that closing the US Department of Education will do none of these things, though. In fact, it's guaranteed to make things worse. 8/8
comment in response to
post
In high-performing education systems there is an understanding that teachers need time to collaborate, develop themselves professionally, & think deeply about how to improve their craft. US teachers are lucky if they get to go to the bathroom at a time that coincides with their body's needs. 7/
comment in response to
post
*More teacher planning and collaboration time - Even though there are plenty of countries where students go to school more days than in the US, American teachers spend more time in front of students than almost any other country in the world. How can that be? Well… 6/
comment in response to
post
*Holistic curricula - Instead of focusing solely on "core" academic subjects like reading/math, high-performing ed systems embrace the arts, humanities, physical activity, & recess. Kids are developed as holistic individuals and not as cogs in a future economy to benefit wealthy business owners. 5/
comment in response to
post
*Lower societal inequality - High-performing systems have less poverty & income disparity, universal health care, publicly funded childcare & preschool, & a strong social safety net. This means kids come to school healthier, better prepared, & with less family stress impacting their learning. 4/
comment in response to
post
*Lower education system inequality - US is one of the only countries where schools w/ the most need (those in poorer areas) get less funding. This is due to funding structure of using property taxes & local $ rather than federal funding to pay for education. Dismantling USDoEd makes this worse. 3/
comment in response to
post
*Highly qualified and respected teachers - Countries that have the highest-performing education systems tend to have well-paid, very respected, and highly qualified teachers. Some, like Finland, require a Masters degree to teach - and compensate those in the profession accordingly. 2/
comment in response to
post
And, from Louisiana:
comment in response to
post
The answer is structural changes that increase pay, teacher morale, societal respect for teachers, etc. without that, tech is just one more thing added to our plate. We’ve been sold the “this tech will make your job easier” line too many times. It’s never been true. It won’t be with AI either.
comment in response to
post
I’m not sure I’d agree there. A role? Sure. An *obvious* role in *every* classroom? I won’t go that far. Give me a good teacher with no tech over a mediocre teacher with great tech every day of the week. The tech is only as good as the teacher who incorporates it.
comment in response to
post
Agree. It’s important we center the teacher, not the tech.
comment in response to
post
Good teaching makes edtech useful.
comment in response to
post
Done!