This year, Eli Manning becomes eligible to be voted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Would you vote him in?
Would you vote him in?
Comments
And it’s possible no player has ever engendered a wider spectrum of emotions from his team’s fans.
Eli Manning and the Hall of Fame argument that may never go away ⤵️
Even then, his TD:INT ratio those 2 seasons: 23:20 and 31:25.
He'd be benched for Daniel Jones in 2024.
So, Hall of Fame for Eli? Fuck. No.
So Andy Dalton should be out because his teams DLs were worse?
His career W/L says he shouldn't be 118-188 in comparison Peyton has 186-79 Brees is 172
I vote no
Wow, what illustrious company!
Eli was almost Tebow level!
I’d say yes.
It doesn't mean they're all time greats.
/s tag incase you missed it.
Also, Eli's in.
He’s in.
I don’t love it. But he beat Brady 2x, including the Pats “perfect” season.
He’s a 🔒
He just wasn’t good enough!
Qb1: 62% 4044yds 29 tds 19 it's
Qb2: 60% 4108y 26td 18int
Qb3: 58% 4042y 24td 23int
Qb4: 63% 3590y 24td 12int
One of those only has one ring, one has none. Eli has 2, along with 2 SB mvps.
Who is who 👀
Eli should be in, I don’t even know why this is a debate. The convo starts and stops at him having 2 SB wins and MVPs —as the obvious underdog—
NO.
#EliManning didn’t just play football; he seized moments. Twice, he dethroned the Patriots in Super Bowls, turning high-pressure games into career-defining victories. Critics doubted, but he thrived when it mattered most.
#TheArtOfWar #EliManning #ClutchPerformance #ProfessionalSuccess #LeadershipUnderPressure #StrategicWins
That gets him in
1. As a Giants fan, i'm biased
2. Two SB MVPs
3. Consistency at the toughest position in the NFL for 15 years
I’m still very fucking bitter. It’s going to take more time. Hell I’m still pissed at the Roughing the Passer penalty on Sugar Ray Hamilton, the Hagler loss to sugar Ray and the Jack Hamilton fast ball to Tony C’s head.
This is just like the early 00s when every NYC person thought anyone who had 3 at bats or more with the 90s Yankees was a hall of famer.
If T Brady is in then the guy that beat him TWICE should be there too. Also he has that whole undermine the draft process as part of his legacy.
One of the most clutch players ever
A symbol of the underdog mentality the Giants had for decades.
Anyone arguing he shouldn't be is kidding themselves. Only one QB whose is both eligible for the Hall of Fame and won multiple Super Bowls isn't in the Hall.
When it came to a fourth quarter no huddle offense, he earned it.
But I’m biased.
Dan Fouts (Never won Super Bowl)
Warren Moon (Never won Super Bowl)
Jim Kelly (Never won Super Bowl)
And Eli has better numbers than all three of them and two Super Bowl rings - yep, he should be in.
Tougher decision on P. Rivers.
2x Super Bowl MVP
57000+ yards passing
366 TD passes
4x Pro Bowl
He’s no Tom Brady - but he beat Tom Brady. Twice. In the Super Bowl
It’s no contest. He belongs in the Hall.
2 luckiest SB wins in history. Mediocre at best.